HOW TO WORK ON YOUR GROUP PROJECT: WHAT IS EXPECTED
Projects are an important component of this course. You will be
expected
to complete several projects this semester. Each project will present
you
with a substantial problem to solve. Solving the problem will take one
to two weeks. You will be working in assigned groups of two or three
students.
All the members of your project group will receive the same grade for
the
project. Here are some words of advice and encouragement along with the
rules of the game.
First of all, this is a major, lengthy assignment that counts a
significant
portion of your course grade. To do well you should start immediately
and
work on it every day. You will probably need all the days you have been
given in order to complete your project by the day it is due.
- Group Work. Be sure you get off to an early start, because
projects
require extensive thought and development of ideas, as well as clear,
concise
write-ups. Your group should meet right after the project is assigned
to
map out a solution strategy, and several more times during the actual
solution
period. Often, when you are writing up your report, you find that there
is an error in your proposed solution. Therefore, you should aim to
have
your report completed well before it is due.
- Start today. Let your subconscious work for you. It can do
amazing
things if it has the raw material to work with. If you immerse yourself
in the project, solutions will come to you at the strangest times. You
should plan your first group meeting as soon as possible, but before
that
first meeting, you should have read the project carefully and given it
some thought. Read the entire project to see what it's all about. Do
not
worry too much about the details the first time through. Read the
project
today!
- Next, read the project very carefully and make a list of any
unfamiliar
words or concepts you encounter. If concepts appear that you're not
sure
about, you must understand those ideas before you can do the project.
Even
if you understand all the words and terms, don't assume that the
project
is easy. If you wait until the last few days or so to start, it is
doubtful
you will be able to finish on time; at best you will produce an
inferior
report.
- At your first group meeting, you should plan a method of attack
and
you may wish to divide the labor among the group. Different members of
the group may perform different tasks, but all members of the group are
expected to understand all parts of the solution. Regular group
meetings
to discuss the progress of the solution are important.
- It is important that everyone in the group participate in the
work
of the group. In particular, everyone needs to understand how the
problem
is being solved. To insure this, you should avoid having the same
person
always act as leader or as recorder of your group. Be aware that any group
member may be asked to report on the group's progress or final results.
- Efficiency. Here are some suggestions to help you work more
efficiently.
As soon as the group is finished
with a part of the project you should
write that part of the report. This will help you avoid the
"all-nighter"
syndrome the day before the project is due.
Word processing will be a big help since it makes it easy to make
changes. Word processing also makes it possible
for different people to share in the typing of the report.
However, you should spend much more time
on the content of your report (solution, explanation, deciding what
sentences to use) than on the printing (actual typing, formatting,
font-foolishness,
etc.).
You should avoid a group setup where one person does the
"thinking"
and a different person is responsible for "production" of the
report.
- Meetings. Meetings should probably have some structure and a time
limit.
You should each think about the project before the meeting. After two
hours
almost any meeting is much less productive. Before the end of any
meeting
you should decide what is to be done (and who is doing it) before the
next
meeting.
- You may need to do some outside reading. In addition to your
textbook,
there are lots of books in the library that contain information that
might
be helpful to you.
- After you have worked a bit every day on the project, you will
find
certain parts easy and you will have completed those parts. You will
have
identified the hard parts and have begun to zero in on the obstacles.
You
are beginning to become the master of your project. You are so familiar
with it that it is easy to sit and work on it if you have a spare
minute
or two. I recommend you work on the project some every day and keep a
journal
to record your progress.
- Consultations. You should feel free to consult me about your
projects.
In fact, on the first project, I require it. I will try to point you
away from undue difficulties without "giving
away" the heart of the project.
- Formal Write-up. Each group will turn in one paper. When you have
done
the work necessary to complete the project, you need to prepare it in
written
form. The paper you turn in should have a mix of equations, formulas,
tables,
graphs, and prose to support your conclusions. Use complete sentences,
good grammar and correct punctuation. Spelling is also important. The
prose
should be written in order to convey to the reader an explanation of
what
you have done. Annotate any derivations that appear in the report and
explain
the steps in your reasoning. Integrate explanations with calculations;
i.e., do not present a calculation page separate from your
explanation - weave the two together. In writing your report,
assume the reader is a
student in similar class who has not worked on this project. You will
be
graded on your written presentation as well as, if not more than, the
mathematical
content.
Your final report is to be typed on standard 8.5 x 11" paper.
Equations
may be neatly hand-written-in. Graphs are to be clearly drawn or
computer
produced, but always well-labeled. Be sure that the names of all the
members
of the group appear on the cover page.
Take as much pride in your report as you would if you were writing
it
for an employer on whom you wish to make a favorable impression.
- Peer Evaluation. Each member will separately hand in an
evaluation
of the other members' performance with the final report. This report is
confidential; I am the only person who will see it. Handwritten notes
are
fine. These should include: 1) a few sentences on how well the group
cooperated
and on how evenly the workload was distributed, and 2) an
estimate of the percentage of the work that each group member did. I
will
not use these reports in
assigning grades on the project. At the end of
the semester, however, the totality of all peer reports is one of the
inputs I will
use to decide course grades. You may also include in the peer reports
any
suggestions, improvements or comments about the project.