• College of Law
• Oregon Law Commission
  • OLC Recommended Legislation
  • Law Reform Process
  • Commissioners & Staff
  • Calendar
  • Work Groups
    • 2011-2013
      • Probate Modernization
      • OLC Meetings
      • Adoption
      • Child Abuse
      • Decisions by Disqualified Public Officials
      • Judicial Selection
        • Meeting 02-20-2013
        • Meeting 12-03-2012
        • Meeting 11-19-2012
        • Meeting 10-08-2012
        • Meeting 09-10-12
        • Meeting 08-20-2012
        • Meeting 07-16-2012
        • Meeting 04-23-2012
        • Meeting 06-11-2012
      • Juvenile
      • Uniform Collateral Consequences of Conviction Act
      • Uniform Unsworn Foreign Declarations Act
      • Revised Uniform Law on Notarial Acts
      • UCC Article 9
      • Uniform Law Enforcement Access to Entity Information Act
      • Uniform Trust Code
    • 2009-2011
    • 2007-2009
    • 2005-2007
    • 2003-2005
    • 2001-2003
    • 1999-2001
  • Bills, Minutes & Reports
  • Related Resources
  • Contact Us

Appellate Judicial Selection Meeting: 08-20-2012

• Time: 9:30 a.m. - 11:30 a.m.
• Location: Oregon State Bar Offices - Columbia Room; 16037 SW Upper Boones Ferry Rd., Tigard, OR 97224

• CLE Approval for 8/20/12 Meeting
• Agenda
• Summary of 7/16/12 Meeting of Appellate Judicial Selection Work Group
• Charts for 8/20/12 Meeting
• Materials for Agenda Item III. Appellate Judicial System Goals and Desired Qualifications
• Materials for Agenda Item IV. Judicial Evaluations
• Materials for Agenda Item V. Judicial Recusal Rules
• Materials for Agenda Item VI. Proposals for Reform in Oregon

CLE Approval for 8/20/12 Meeting

• CLE Recordkeeping Form (pdf)

Agenda

• Agenda for 8/20/12 (pdf)

Summary of 7/16/12 Meeting of Appellate Judicial Selection Work Group

• Summary of 7/16/12 Meeting (pdf)

Charts for 8/20/12 Meeting

• Appellate Judicial Selection Options Chart (pdf)

• JPEs and Recusal Chart (pdf)

• Judicial Term Lengths (pdf)

Materials for Agenda Item III. Appellate Judicial System Goals and Desired Qualifications

• Goals and Desired Qualities of Judges Revised August 2012 (pdf)

Materials for Agenda Item IV. Judicial Evaluations

• IAALS Excerpts Shared Expectations Judicial Accountability (pdf)

• IAALS Appellate JPE - Official Programs (pdf)

• IAALS Appellate JPE One Pager (pdf)

• Hawaii Judicial Selection and Evaluation (pdf)

• Vermont Statutes (pdf)

• District of Columbia Statutes Rules Eval (pdf)

• AJS Excerpt Model Judicial Selection and Evaluation Provisions (pdf)

• Alaska Provisions (pdf)

• ABA Guidelines with Comments on Judicial Performance Evaluation (pdf)

• IAALS Evaluation Appellate Judges Post Conf. Report (pdf)

Materials for Agenda Item V. Judicial Recusal Rules

• Memo re: Judicial Disqualification Rules (pdf)

• ABA Rule 2.11 2011 Disqualification (pdf)

• ABA 2011 House of Delegate Resolution 107 and Report (pdf)

• ABA Rule 2.11 Working Draft July 2012 (pdf)

• AJS Disqualification Contributions 3.8.12 (pdf)

• Example Appendix to AJS Article (pdf)

• ABA Written Testimony 2012 Meeting Discussing Rule 2.11 (pdf)

Materials for Agenda Item VI. Proposals for Reform in Oregon

• A. "A Modest Proposal for Selection of Oregon Judges" forthcoming in Albany Law Review, by De Muniz and Schradle (available upon request)

• B. Proposal from John DiLorenzo, Jr. (pdf)

• C.