[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Center for Dispute Resolution
Center for Dispute Resolution
About CDR
CDR Faculty
Curriculum
Certificate in Dispute Resolution
Simulation Bank
CDR Alumni
Related LInks


Recent Developments
Subscribe Unsubscribe Recent News News Archive


2007 Newsletters

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

December 31, 2006 - January 6, 2007

1. Mediation: Mediation can be binding against a party even if she is not present. (Idaho).

2. Arbitration: Failing to remit a filing fee, which results in a default order on pending arbitration, waives the party’s right to
compel arbitration.
(United States District Court, E.D. Pa.).

3. Arbitration: To be eligible for confirmation of a final judgment of an arbitrator, the award must not have been vacated,
modified or corrected and, under the Arbitration Act, the party must apply for confirmation within one year from the date
of final judgment.
(11th Cir.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

January 7, 2007 - January 13, 2007

1. Mediation: When a local law provides that the parties must personally attend mediation, the court, using
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16, may require the absent party to pay the other party’s reasonable expenses
incurred due to the noncompliance.
(M.D. Fla.).

2. Arbitration: A party seeking to vacate an arbitration award for “evident partiality” with respect to the arbitrator
must prove the circumstances were powerfully suggestive of bias.
(United States Dist. Court, D. N.J.).

3. Arbitration: California’s Mandatory Fee Agreement voids client arbitration agreements with attorneys.
(Cal. App. 4th Dist., Jan. 9, 2007).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

January 14, 2007 - January 20, 2007

1. Mediation: When a local law provides that the parties must personally attend mediation, the court, using
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16, may require the absent party to pay the other party’s reasonable expenses
incurred due to the noncompliance.
(M.D. Fla.).

2. Arbitration: A party seeking to vacate an arbitration award for “evident partiality” with respect to the arbitrator
must prove the circumstances were powerfully suggestive of bias.
(United States Dist. Court, D. N.J.).

3. Arbitration: California’s Mandatory Fee Agreement voids client arbitration agreements with attorneys.
(Cal. App. 4th Dist., Jan. 9, 2007).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

January 21, 2007 - January 27, 2007

1. Arbitration: An arbitration award will be enforced when the arbitrator acted within the scope of his authority, was not being
charged for fraud or dishonesty in making the award, and when he was arguably construing the contract, even if he made a
serious error in interpreting the contract.
(6th Cir. (Mich.)).

2. Arbitration: A party may implicitly waive his right to arbitration through excessive delay, expense, or damage to the other party’s
legal position.
(N.D Miss.).

3. Arbitration: A seaman’s agreement to arbitrate related claims precludes litigation of re-injury. (5th Cir. (La.)).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

January 28, 2007 - February 3, 2007

1. Arbitration: When a district court denies a stay pending arbitration, there may be an abuse of discretion if the pending
arbitration is likely to resolve issues material to the lawsuit.
(7th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: When a party expressly limits their motion to compel arbitration to the issue of arbitrability, the trial court’s
determination is a final judgment that cannot be appealed
. (Cal.App. 2 Dist.).

3. Arbitration: A party’s attempt to withdraw from a collective bargaining agreement does not necessarily invalidate the
arbitration clause that is part of that agreement.
(8th Cir.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

February 4, 2007 - February 11, 2007

1. Arbitration: An arbitrator’s choice of law does not violate public policy unless it undermines an asserted fundamental public
policy of one party’s forum state.
(8th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: An agreement that includes a statement showing intent bind the parties “now and in the future,” coupled with an
informed consent provision will force the parties into arbitration for later treatments.
(Cal.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

February 11, 2007 - February 17, 2007

1. Arbitration: Equitable estoppel can fulfill the writing requirement under Section 16 of the Federal Arbitration Act. (C.A.2 (N.Y.)).

2. Arbitration: A judge has jurisdiction to vacate an arbitration award when the arbitrator considers factors outside the scope
of the agreement.
(Ohio).

3. Arbitration: When a party does not request arbitration for disputed attorney’s fees within the specified time period of the
Mandatory Fee Arbitration Act, the right is waived and is subject to the dispute resolution process enumerated in the
retainer agreement.
(Cal. App. 2 Dist.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

February 18, 2007 - February 24, 2007

1. Arbitration: Only disputes that the parties have affirmatively agreed to arbitrate pursuant to the language of their arbitration
provision will be arbitrated.
(Cal.App. 1 Dist.).

2. Arbitration: A challenge to an arbitration provision of an employee benefit plan governed by ERISA does not, in and of itself,
confer federal jurisdiction.
(N.D. Tex.).

3. Arbitration: Filing a motion to set aside a default judgment does not constitute sufficient participation in the judicial process
to warrant an implied waiver of enforcement of an arbitration clause.
(Tex.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

February 25, 2007 - March 3, 2007

1. Arbitration: A lender may waive the right to pursue arbitration when he proceeds substantially into foreclosure proceedings
and does not enforce his otherwise enforceable right to proceed to arbitration.
(Ky.App.).

2. Arbitration: Parties must manifest a clear intent to apply standards other than those specified in the Federal Arbitration
Act.
(C.A.3(N.J.)).

3. Arbitration: When there is ambiguous language about the scope of rewards available, the contract is to be read in favor of
the arbitrator’s findings of fact.
(C.A.5(Tex.)).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

March 4, 2007 - March 10, 2007

1. Arbitration: An arbitration clause is unenforceable under the FAA when it does not have a nexus with interstate
commerce.
(Ala.).

2. Arbitration: A valid arbitration agreement is enforceable against a debtor who files an adversary proceeding in
bankruptcy court if arbitration of the proceeding does not inherently conflict with the Bankruptcy Code.

(Bkrtcy.M.D.Ala.).

3. Arbitration: While courts generally try to uphold arbitration agreements, even where the contract provisions are
somewhat uncertain and indefinite, disputes that arise outside the scope of the arbitration provision will not be
arbitrated.
(Kan. App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

March 11, 2007 - March 17, 2007

1. Arbitration: Arbitration clauses signed between a company and a client can preclude a separate suit against
that company’s employees.
(C.A.7).

2. Arbitration: Absent a legislative directive, a spousal relationship alone does not confer authority of one spouse
to bind the other spouse to an arbitration provision in a nursing home admission contract.
(Cal.App. 4 Dist.).

3. Arbitration: A district court may confirm an arbitrator’s partial award that is independent and separate from the
remaining issues before the arbitrator and can be finally determined without reference to the remaining issues.
(S.D.N.Y.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

March 18, 2007 - March 24, 2007

1. Arbitration: A district court has broad discretion to exclude or admit an arbitrator’s decision relating to a federal employment
discrimination case.
(N.D. Iowa).

2. Arbitration: An arbitrator exceeds his powers when he ignores the clear language of the parties’ contract that requires an
award of attorney fees to the prevailing party.
(Ill.App. 1 Dist.).

3. Arbitration: The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may not be enforced through arbitration. (Md.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

March 25, 2007 - March 31, 2007

1. Arbitration: When a petition for arbitration governed by the FAA is improperly denied, the court will issue a writ
of mandamous upon showing that the claim falls within the scope of a valid arbitration agreement and the parties
have not waived their right to pursue arbitration.
(Tex.App.-Hous.(1 Dist.)).

2. Arbitration: An arbitration panel may require parties to execute hold harmless agreements to solidify the immunity
accorded to arbitrators as a quasi-judicial body.
(N.D.Ill.).

3. Arbitration: Under the Massachusetts Arbitration Act, judicial efficiency is not enough to overcome the Court’s
considerable interest in promoting arbitration.
(Mass.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

April 22, 2007 - April 28, 2007

1. Arbitration: Bank acquisition of arbitration party prior to final award did not make Bank party to the arbitration and
require arbitrator to disclose a relationship with Bank.
(Cal.App. 1 Dist.).

2. Mediation: Parties adding attorney review provisions to mediation without the other party’s consent voids mediation
agreement.
(N.J. Super.A.D.).76

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

April 29, 2007 - May 5, 2007

1. Arbitration: Failure to fully comply with private organization’s notice requirements equals ‘undue means’ in Minnesota. (Minn.App.).

2. Arbitration: Clause calling for non-binding mediation or srbitration does not require FAA treatment. (S.D. Fla.).

3. Arbitration: Employer exemption from Title VII cannot be used to dismiss discrimination claims brought under § 1981. (C.A. 4 (Md.)).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

May 6, 2006 - May 12, 2007

1. Arbitration: Representation during arbitration by same attorney in related matter not sufficient for collateral
estoppel
. (D.Del).

2. Arbitration: First Circuit holds that administrative agency cannot set aside statutorily-mandated arbitration
decision unless it violates general agency policy.
(C.A. 1(Puerto Rico)).

3. Arbitration: Suit to reconsider arbitration award time barred under FAA after three months and limitation does
not toll for moving party.
(D.D.C).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

May 13, 2007 - May 19, 2007

1. Arbitration: Fifth Circuit finds that awards are enforceable as long as they are rationally inferable from the agreement,
says arbitrator errors are one of the disadvantages of arbitration.
(C.A. 5).

2. Arbitration: No conceivable violation of public policy found to vacate arbitration award under Railway Labor Act. (C.A.6).

3. Mediation: Termination of parental rights permitted where parent violated strict provisions of mediated settlement
agreement which did not allow for “substantial compliance.”.
(Tex.App.-Austin).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

May 20, 2007 - May 26, 2007

1. Arbitration: District court refuses to enforce arbitration award where foreign court set aside arbitration
award.
(C.A.D.C).

2. Arbitration: Arbitration is valid even when employees refuse to sign a receipt of the agreement. (C.A.5).

3. Mediation: Texas court follows Fifth Circuit, holds parties to own sequence of dispute resolution process
before compelling arbitration.
(Tex.App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

May 27, 2007 - June 2, 2007

1. Arbitration: 9th Circuit declines to vacate award made moot by federal case. (C.A. 9).

2. Arbitration: Employer’s arbitration agreement with employee does not bar action by E.E.O.C. when employer and
employee settle claim.
(C.A. 10).

3. Mediation: Attorney in mediation is protected from deposition when other means of obtaining information is available
to opposing party.
(D.Kan).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

June 3, 2007 - June 9, 2007

1. Arbitration: 11th Circuit holds United Nations Convention on foreign arbitral awards preempts the federal
Seamen’s Wage Act.
(11th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: Creditor waives arbitration right by failing to timely raise agreement and delay prejudices
debtor.
(8th Cir.).

3. Mediation: Texas court holds mediated settlement cannot be used to modify divorce decree. (Tex.App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

June 10, 2007 - June 16, 2007

1. Arbitration: Fifth Circuit joins other federal circuits, says fraud in inducement must have been specifically aimed
at the arbitration clause.
(5th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: Arbitrator could not disregard Joint Statement by union and employer which supplemented CBA. (3rd Cir.).

3. Mediation: Mediation agreement satisfied even when payment was tended late. (Ind.App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

June 17, 2007 - June 23, 2007

1. Arbitration: Court will not decide foreign arbitration law where courts of the foreign country are available to
the parties to rule on the facts.
(E.D.N.Y.).

2. Arbitration: Arbitration award amount irrelevant in determining jurisdiction when complaint filed prior to
arbitration met amount in controversy requirement.
(4th Cir.).

3. Mediation: District of Idaho rules that compelling production of documents resulting from mediation efforts
would have a chilling effect on alternative dispute resolution.
(D. Idaho).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

June 24, 2007 - June 30, 2007

1. Arbitration: Contract of adhesion which mandates arbitration silent as to class actions ruled not unconscionable
by Oregon Court of Appeals and referred to arbitrator who would make determination as to application of arbitration
clause to the class.
(Or.App.).

2. Arbitration: Party may not claim arbitrator acted outside scope of authority on appeal when party did not raise claim
during the mediation.
(Cal.App. 2 Dist.).

3. Mediation: Non-prevailing party cannot be ordered to pay mediation fees as taxable costs under 28 U.S.C. § 1920. (5th Cir.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

July 1, 2007 - July 7, 2007

1. Arbitration: Arbitration award similar to jury verdict for purposes of interest, allows prejudgment interest only of
liquidated damages.
(Wash.).

2. Arbitration: Collective bargaining agreements requiring waiver of statutory rights under ADA and Title VII held
unenforceable.
(S.D.N.Y.).

3. Mediation: Parties cannot capitalize on their own mistake in violation of mediated agreement. (Ky.App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

July 7, 2007 - July 14, 2007

1. Arbitration: Once aware of a potential conflict, failure to investigate further is grounds to vacate for evident
partiality.
(2nd Cir.).

2. Arbitration: Arbitration award upheld where part of award included damages from previous lawsuit not including
prevailing party.
(4th Cir.).

3. Mediation: Judge’s in camera examination of documents produced in confidential mediation determined that
non-mediation party’s interest in justice did not outweigh the need to preserve the confidentiality of mediation.
(D. Conn.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

July 15, 2007 - July 21, 2007

1. Arbitration: Third-party beneficiaries bound to arbitration clause even where no official agency relationship was
established.
(5th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: The mere possibility of arbitral prejudice is insufficient to justify setting aside an award when arbitration
clause does not require party’s selected arbitrator to be neutral.
(8th Cir.)

3. Mediation: Easier to set aside mediated agreements which deprive biological parents of child custody. (Fla.App.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

July 22, 2007 - July 28, 2007

1. Arbitration: Failure to settle grievance short of arbitration is not irrational or unfair to union member. (7th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: Continued employment may constitute acquiescence of arbitration clause to at will employees. (5th Cir.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

July 29, 2007 - August 4, 2007

1. Arbitration: Liberal notice pleading in federal courts stands in contrast to the great deference accorded to
arbitration awards.
(7th Cir.).

2. Arbitration: Collective bargaining agreement arbitration clauses that waive an employee’s right to a federal
forum with respect to statutory claims are unenforceable.
(2d Cir.).

3. Mediation: Parties’ failure to agree on essential term precludes a finding that parties entered into a binding
settlement agreement.
(N.J. Super.A.D.).

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Updated by Julie K. Gehring
Willamette University College of Law

 

 

[an error occurred while processing this directive]