Recent Developments in Dispute Resolution Newsletter
(Willamette University
College Of Law)
August 20,
1998
Arbitration:
Arbitrators Decision To Reinstate Employee Upheld
Mediation: Mediation Summary Not Admissible As Evidence
ADR Online: AAA Moves Deeper Into Cyberspace
ADR Online: Legal Issues Concerning The Year 2000 "Millennium
Bug"
ADR Online: CDRC Standards Of Practice For California Mediators
ADR Online: National Dispute Resolution Organizations Seek
New Structure
Arbitration:
Arbitrators Decision To Reinstate Employee Upheld
Homestake Mining Company v. United Steelworkers of America, AFL-CIO
(8th Cir. 8/17/98)
Homestake Mining
Company (Homestake) appeals from the district court's denial of
its motion to vacate a labor arbitration award that reinstated Stacy
Oberle, a Homestake employee who was discharged for alleged safety
violations. Homestake contends that the award failed to draw its
essence from the collective bargaining agreement and that the award
should be set aside as contrary to public policy. The relevant collective
bargaining agreement authorized Homestake to discharge employees
"for just cause," and incorporated by reference federal mine safety
regulations as workplace safety rules in the mine. The Court
of Appeals affirmed the district court explaining that the arbitrators
decision was insulated from review because the decision was "neither
completely irrational [nor] evidences a manifest disregard for law."
[Full Decision On Westlaw: 1998 WL 477214]
Mediation:
Mediation Summary Not Admissible As Evidence
Kitchen and Kitchen Farms, Inc., v. Kitchen (Mich. App. 7/31/98)
After brothers
William and Robert Kitchen dissolved their partnership, plaintiff
William Kitchen brought an action for prescriptive easement, permanent
license, and estoppel for use of irrigation equipment which ran
over Robert Kitchen's land. After a failed mediation, Robert
filed a motion for summary disposition and submitted William's mediation
summary as evidence of the frivolousness of plaintiff's claim.
The court rejected Robert's argument that the summary was admissible
because it did not pertain to the merits of William's original claim
and upheld the policy of supporting honest and reprisal free mediation
encapsulated in Michigan statute 2.403(j).
[Full Decision On Westlaw: 1998 WL 436090]
ADR Online:
AAA Moves Deeper Into Cyberspace
By Cindy Fazzi
A number of
services recently launched in cyberspace by the American Arbitration
Association have been drawing considerable attention and use.
The Association is providing a wide range of information to millions
of Internet users all over the world through a highly popular web
site, and other on-line services. The AAA is also offering
on-line case administration services under a special pilot project
called Virtual Magistrate, where parties in computer network-related
disputes may now choose to resolve their disagreements through online
arbitration or fact finding.
Details:
http://www.adr.org/drt/cyberspace_article.html
ADR Online:
Legal Issues Concerning The Year 2000 "Millennium Bug"
By Jeff Jinnett
The well know
computer problem, variously known as the "Year 2000", "Y2K", "Century
Date Change" or "Millennium Bug" problem, faces many companies.
Though many computer experts have discussed many of the technical
issues surrounding the Year 2000 problem, little has been published
concerning the related legal issues. This article is intended to
provide a summary discussion of some of the major legal issues which
may arise due to the Year 2000.
Details:
http://www.pli.edu/frm-book-lo.html
ADR Online:
CDRC Standards Of Practice For California Mediators
The California
Dispute Resolution Counsel recently unveiled a discussion draft
of Standards of Practice for California Mediators. Their goal
is to solicit input on the draft from mediators throughout California
and beyond. They want this draft to truly encompass all of
the styles and practices of mediation currently being practiced,
while at the same time, guiding the high ethical standards required
of mediators. When completed and approved by their Board,
these Standards will serve to as a resource for courts, legislators,
educators, students and practitioners in the mediation field.
Details:
http://www.mediate.com/wideopen/cdrc/articles/news_standards.htm
ADR Online:
National Dispute Resolution Organizations Seek New Structure
"The National
Association for Community Mediation, the National Institute for
Dispute Resolution and its Conflict Resolution Education Network,
and the Society of Professionals in Dispute Resolution have entered
into an important negotiation, exploring the benefits of developing
an organizational structure which allows closer collaboration. The
three national dispute resolution organizations agreed to explore
forms of confederation as a result of a conversation that representatives
had in Washington, DC on May 14 and 15. The Boards of each
organization have agreed to a Memorandum of Understanding that sets
a goal of developing a new structure within three years. They have
also agreed to a set of principles that will guide their discussions.
The negotiations are the result of a shared sense that a new structure
offers opportunities for long term stability and for expanding the
array of services available to each group's membership."
Details:
http://www.spidr.org
Recent Developments in Dispute Resolution
Willamette Law Online
- Willamette University
College of Law
Faculty Editor: Ross Runkel - rrunkel@willamette.edu
Student Editor: Kevin Cheatham - kcheatha@willamette.edu
Student Editorial Board: David
Ward, Alison Hohengarten,
Scott Perry
Website: http://www.willamette.edu/law/wlo/dis-res/
(Past Newsletters: Available Online At The Website Under "DR Newsletter")
Revised
by Kevin Cheatham,
Third Year Law Student
Willamette
University College of Law, Salem, Oregon 97301
|