Inadequacy of Punishment...
Juvenile Hall vs. Jail
 
 
A major frame used by the media in this situation was that the  
punishment the boys received was not appropriately harsh, considering the crime they committed.  

They shot at their friends, classmates, and teachers, killing four and wounding ten.

 
    They were sentenced to be confined in a "juvenile center" perhaps until they are 21. The length of their
detention will be up to juvenile authorities. The judge in the case also added on 90 days in jail in the case
that the boys were released before they are 21. They were punished to the maximum extent that the law
allowed, but articles focused on the fact that they could be released before they were 21, and would be
allowed to buy and use guns on their release.  Ads like the one below reinforce the fear people have that
guns could end up in the wrong hands.
Photo: Free-market gallery (http://free-market.com/images/gallery/#rkba)
 

    On the other hand, an adult who was guilty of the same crime would likely be facing life in jail or perhaps
even the death penalty. Articles also said that the boys were sent to a "juvenile center" not a jail or a prison
since "juvenile center" sounds much less harsh. This is a concept addressed by "Contestable Categories and Public Opinions" (Edelmen, 1979) when he discusses how certain words can have a strong influence on how the public feels about certain issues.

In these ways, the media makes their punishment seem too short, too lenient, and too soft.
 
 
The media also focused on the way the punishment was not harsh enough for the crime. The judge who  
presided over their trial was quoted as saying  
"here the punishment will not fit the crime".  

The two thoughts that the punishment was not adequate, but that it was the harshest allowed by law suggests that the legal system is to blame. Many articles said that the system is not designed to chastise teenage criminals to an appropriate extent. Since we have teenagers in our society that engage in criminal action, many articles imply that the legal system where teens are concerned must be revised so they are punished appropriately.

 
  Back to main page